Fabian shows up to Goth Bully's Friendsgiving gathering with a store bought pumpkin pie. Little does he know, Goth Bully has a little surprise waiting for him when he walks in the door. Seeing his pitiful excuse for a dish, he lets loose his frustration on Fabian, taking his store bought pumpkin pie and nailing him right in the face with it. He continues this onslaught with pie after pie in his face and dumping some gloppy slop on his head. He absolutely trashes him with cranberry sauce, cornbread batter, and pumpkin pie filling. After the whole ordeal, Fabian takes it all in good humor and they both laugh looking forward to watching the game.